On a plant extract specification sheet, a ratio such as 10:1 and an assay such as “chlorogenic acid 5% by HPLC” look like two ways of saying how strong an extract is. They measure different things. The ratio describes a process input; the assay describes a measured output. Buying on ratio alone leaves potency undefined.
- Ratio = how much raw material went into one unit of extract.
- Assay = how much of a named marker is actually present, measured by a stated method.
- Carriers and moisture change apparent strength without changing the ratio.
- Always specify marker + range + method + carrier.
What an extract ratio actually means
A 10:1 extract is produced from roughly ten parts of dried raw material to yield one part of finished extract. It is a mass-balance statement about the process. It says nothing about how much of the target compound survived extraction, how the material was dried, or how much carrier was added afterwards.
Two 10:1 extracts of the same herb can differ substantially if one used water and the other a hydroethanolic solvent, if one was spray-dried with 30% maltodextrin and the other vacuum-dried without carrier, or if the raw material came from different harvest windows.
Why the assay number needs a method
“5% by HPLC” and “5% by UV” are not equivalent results. UV-Vis methods can respond to structurally related compounds and over-report a marker; a properly validated HPLC or UHPLC method separates the target peak and quantifies it against a reference standard. Gravimetric or “total” methods are broader still.
| Expression | Measures | Main limitation |
|---|---|---|
| 10:1 ratio | Raw material to finished extract mass | No potency information |
| Assay by HPLC/UHPLC | A named, separated marker compound | Requires a defined reference standard |
| Assay by UV-Vis | A compound class or chromophore | Can over-report due to related compounds |
| Total polysaccharides | A broad carbohydrate fraction | Not equivalent to beta-glucans |
Carriers, moisture and “100% pure” claims
Spray drying often requires a carrier such as maltodextrin or dextrin; anti-caking agents may be used for flowability. These are legitimate process aids, but they dilute the extract. Ask for the carrier percentage and the loss-on-drying limit, then check whether the assay is expressed on the finished powder as supplied or on a dried, carrier-free basis.
How to write an unambiguous specification
- Identity: Latin name, plant part, extraction solvent.
- Strength: ratio and named marker with an acceptance range.
- Method: HPLC/UHPLC with detection wavelength, column type and reference standard.
- Composition: carrier and percentage, moisture limit, mesh size, bulk density.
- Safety: heavy metals, residues, solvents, microbiology, allergens.
- Handling: shelf life, storage, packaging and retest date.
If you are comparing offers from several suppliers, normalise them first: convert each to the same assay basis, then compare price per kilogram of the active marker rather than price per kilogram of powder.
Frequently asked questions
Can I convert a 10:1 ratio into a percentage of active compound?
Not reliably. The conversion depends on the native content of the marker in the raw material, extraction efficiency and any carrier added. Ask for a measured assay instead of estimating.
Does a higher ratio always mean a stronger extract?
No. A 20:1 extract made from poor raw material or heavily diluted with carrier can assay lower than a well-controlled 10:1 extract.
What should we do when a COA reports “complies” instead of a numeric result?
Request the numeric value and the method. “Complies” prevents trend analysis and makes it impossible to compare batches.
Is a carrier-free extract always better?
Not necessarily. Carrier-free powders can be hygroscopic and hard to handle in a tablet or premix line. Choose based on the dosage form and flow requirements.
Need the documentation for your project?
Tell us the ingredient, target specification, quantity and destination market. Our team will send a specification sheet, COA sample and a quotation within 24 hours on working days.
Request a Quote Browse Products
Related topic: specification sheets with method-referenced assays

