Extraction solvent determines which compounds are recovered, which residual-solvent limits apply, and how the powder behaves in the finished product. Water extraction favours polar compounds such as polysaccharides; hydroethanolic extraction covers a broader range including many glycosides and polyphenols; supercritical CO2 is suited to lipophilic fractions such as fatty acids and essential oils. Two extracts from the same raw-material lot made with different solvents are not interchangeable, even when the extract ratio is identical.
- Put the extraction solvent on the specification sheet, not only in the process description.
- Match residual-solvent testing to the applicable ICH Q3C class and the solvents actually used.
- Expect different carrier, moisture and flow behaviour between water and CO2 extracts.
- Re-qualify the material whenever the solvent or drying method changes.
1. Polarity decides what leaves the plant
A solvent extracts what it can dissolve. Water pulls polysaccharides, glycosides, tannins and other polar material; ethanol/water mixtures extend that range to moderately polar polyphenols, alkaloids and saponins; supercritical CO2 is non-polar and recovers lipophilic fractions such as fatty acids, sterols and volatile oils.
That is why a marker defined for one process may be nearly absent in another. A “total polysaccharide” specification is meaningful for a water extract and largely meaningless for a CO2 extract of the same herb.
| Solvent | Typical targets | Specification consequences |
|---|---|---|
| Water | Polysaccharides, glycosides, tannins | Higher microbial sensitivity, more hygroscopic powder |
| Ethanol / water | Polyphenols, saponins, alkaloids, flavonoids | Residual-solvent obligations, broader marker panel |
| Supercritical CO2 | Fatty acids, sterols, lipophilic actives | Oily or semi-solid extract, often needs a carrier |
| Other organic solvents | Specialised purifications | Stricter residual-solvent class and documentation |
2. Residual solvents and the ICH Q3C classes
Where an organic solvent is used, the release specification should name it and set a limit against the applicable ICH Q3C class. Ethanol is a Class 3 solvent with a comparatively permissive limit, while Class 2 solvents require tighter control and a stronger justification. A generic “solvent-free” claim is not a substitute for a result.
For water-only processes, the relevant risk shifts to microbial load and water activity rather than solvent residues. For CO2 extraction, there is effectively no organic solvent residue, but the process may involve a separate step to convert an oily extract into a powder, and that step can introduce a carrier.
- Name every solvent used in extraction and purification.
- Set limits by ICH Q3C class and provide GC headspace results per batch.
- For water extracts, prioritise microbiology, water activity and drying controls.
- For CO2 extracts, declare any carrier or encapsulation step and its percentage.
3. Drying, carriers and physical behaviour
Spray-drying and vacuum-drying produce very different powders. Spray-drying usually needs a carrier such as maltodextrin or dextrin, which dilutes the assay and improves flow; vacuum-dried material can be denser, darker and more hygroscopic. The carrier is part of the specification because it changes the percentage of the marker on an as-is basis.
Set appearance, odour, loss on drying, bulk density, particle size and solubility alongside the marker. These are the fields that determine whether the ingredient runs on a tablet press, dissolves in a beverage premix or disperses in a cosmetic base.
| Parameter | Water extract | CO2 / lipophilic extract |
|---|---|---|
| Form | Dry powder, often hygroscopic | Oil, paste or encapsulated powder |
| Carrier | Common in spray drying | Often required to make a free-flowing powder |
| Key physical risk | Caking, microbial growth | Oxidation, phase separation, rancidity |
| Useful release fields | Moisture, aw, mesh, bulk density | Acid value, peroxide value, carrier percentage |
4. Stability and packaging follow the process
Water extracts with high polysaccharide content are prone to moisture uptake and caking, so a moisture-barrier liner and a desiccant are common. Lipophilic extracts are more exposed to oxidation, so oxygen-barrier packaging, low headspace and an antioxidant strategy matter more. Light-sensitive markers such as trans-resveratrol need light-protective packaging regardless of solvent.
The retest or shelf-life position should be supported by stability data for the specific grade, not borrowed from a different extract of the same plant. A change of drying method or carrier is a change of product.
- Choose the barrier (moisture, oxygen, light) to match the failure mode.
- Support the retest period with grade-specific stability or accelerated data.
- Define storage temperature and humidity on the specification sheet.
- Retest after long or warm transit where the marker is light- or heat-sensitive.
5. Documentation and change control
Because the solvent is a process variable with analytical consequences, it belongs on the versioned specification and on the change-control clause. A switch from water to hydroethanolic extraction, a new drying subcontractor or an added carrier should all trigger re-qualification before the next production order.
The document set is otherwise familiar: a versioned specification with method references, a batch-specific COA, origin and botanical identity evidence, and a retained reference sample for comparison. Our technical team reviews these together when qualifying a new botanical ingredient.
- Solvent, solvent ratio and purification steps on the specification.
- Residual-solvent results matched to the declared solvent list.
- Carrier identity and approximate percentage.
- Written change-notification window covering solvent, drying and carrier.
6. Choosing a process for the application
Start from the finished product, not from the plant. A beverage premix usually needs a water-soluble, low-turbidity extract; a softgel may suit a lipophilic CO2 fraction; a tablet blend needs predictable density and flow. Once the application sets the physical requirements, the solvent choice and the marker definition usually follow.
- Define the finished dosage form, solubility requirement and target marker.
- Shortlist the solvent that recovers that marker with the fewest unwanted co-extracts.
- Set the residual-solvent, carrier and physical fields before requesting samples.
- Qualify three consecutive batches from different raw-material lots before scale-up.
Frequently asked questions
Can I swap a water extract for an ethanol extract with the same ratio?
No. The processes recover different compound groups, so the marker profile, impurity profile and solubility differ. Re-qualify the material and re-check the finished formulation before substituting.
Does CO2 extraction mean no residual-solvent testing is needed?
CO2 leaves no organic solvent residue, but a later step may use solvents or a carrier. Ask for a full process summary and test against whatever the process actually uses.
Why is the carrier part of the specification?
A carrier such as maltodextrin dilutes the marker on an as-is basis and changes flow, density and solubility. Its identity and approximate percentage should be stated on the sheet.
Which stability risks belong to which process?
Water extracts tend to absorb moisture and cake; lipophilic extracts are more exposed to oxidation; light-sensitive markers need light protection in every case. Choose the packaging barrier accordingly.
Need the documentation for your project?
Tell us the ingredient, target specification, quantity and destination market. Our team will send a specification sheet, COA sample and a quotation within 24 hours on working days.
Request a Quote Browse Products
Related topic: extraction solvent selection and botanical specification design

